The Bartholomew Fogarty House at 3101 Riverview Boulevard has entered the market for $2,150,000. This landmark residence – the oldest home in Bradenton and Manatee County – has been impeccably restored to honor its 153-year legacy while introducing refined modern amenities. A distinguished piece of Florida’s architectural heritage, the property is marketed exclusively by Thomas Netzel and Team of Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Downtown Sarasota office. The listing details may be viewed here.
The Fogarty brothers, mariners who established a thriving community and built a boatyard, mercantile, and essential structures in the 1860s, were issued 135 acres by the state, creating the foundations of what is now Bradenton. This home, crafted originally from reclaimed ship parts, was built in 1871 by Captain Bartholomew “Tole” Fogarty, one of Bradenton’s founding figures. This three-story, five-bedroom, 4.5-bath home has been sensitively reimagined to blend its authentic historical charm with contemporary luxury.
Situated on a half-acre with proximity to the Manatee River and backing to picturesque Lewis Park, this estate offers a truly unique opportunity for discerning buyers to own a masterpiece of historical preservation.
Led by the expert craftsmanship of David Windham Construction, retired veterinarian Dr. Harolod Ott completed a dedicated revival of the home. The meticulous two-year renovation preserved hallmark features such as the original oak flooring, finely carved interior doors, and the grand wooden staircase, all while updating the structure to accommodate a luxury lifestyle.
The extensive restoration involved elevating the home and incorporating centralized air conditioning for an ideal living environment. Thoughtful enhancements included creating a spacious, open flow and reconfiguring the upper-level bedrooms to feature elegant walk-in closets and en-suite baths. Of particular note is the third level, an enchanting space designed for children, offering dormer-ceilinged bedrooms, a cozy den, and playful features that evoke a timeless fairytale charm.
The grounds are equally impressive, bordered by the verdant Lewis Park. The expansive backyard offers ample space to accommodate a future pool, while the residence itself is ideally located just minutes from IMG Academy, downtown Bradenton, and the pristine beaches of Anna Maria Island.
“Now awaiting a new family to carry forward its legacy, the Bartholomew Fogarty House stands as a beacon of Bradenton’s rich history, restored with integrity and care,” said Thomas Netzel. “With its unique fusion of historical charm and modern amenities, this property is a testament to Bradenton’s enduring heritage and a one-of-a-kind offering in today’s market.”
About Premier Sotheby’s International Realty
Headquartered in Naples, Florida, Premier Sotheby’s International Realty has over 1,400 sales professionals in 40 locations throughout Florida and North Carolina. Premier Sotheby’s International Realty also benefits from an association with the storied Sotheby’s auction house, established in 1744. The brokerage was founded by The Lutgert Companies, a prominent member of Southwest Florida’s business community since 1964, and is proudly associated with Peerage Realty Partners. For more information, visit premiersothebysrealty.com.
